Performing Energy Contracts: 5 Pitfalls

Energy Business Review | Saturday, October 08, 2022

Government entities should be aware of the pitfalls of energy performance contracts, which present some unique challenges to consider before commencing an expensive infrastructure project.

FREMONT, CA:  Many cash-strapped government entities invest in energy performance or savings contracts to update ageing infrastructure. Under these deals, the capital costs of infrastructure projects must be financed by "guaranteed" savings from improved energy efficiency and decreased operating expenses.

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

Still, in practice, these contracts may be based on meaningless guarantees, leaving city and county governments paying off pricey capital projects for years into the future with little or no cost savings.

Before commencing an expensive infrastructure project, government entities should understand the pitfalls of energy performance contracts, which present unique challenges.  

1. Avoid unnecessary scope items

Utilizing an energy performance contract often comes from contractors and service companies vying for infrastructure work. For example, a contractor may tell a local government that it loses thousands of dollars monthly in increased utility costs and operating charges for ageing facilities.

According to the contractor, the solution is an energy performance contract that will generate sufficient "savings" to pay for the project's cost. With the pledge of a project that will pay for itself, the contractor may propose summing items to the scope of work that is not priorities for the government entity. For example, what began as a project to address specific public facilities may expand to a city-wide project to renovate HVAC systems, lighting, plumbing, and perhaps even water meter and billing systems.

Although the alleged "guarantees," energy performance contracts are not risk-free. Governments should avoid utilizing energy performance contracts to finance unnecessary upgrades as part of a package deal, specifically when the project delays other critical infrastructure work.

2. Employ an outside consultant for project evaluation and verification

Few government entities have the skill to fully evaluate an energy performance contract and measure its supposed savings. The savings calculation is complicated and often obscures the true nature of the "guarantees." Cities and counties thus should regard engaging an experienced outside consultant to recognize issues with the contract structure and project scope before the deal is completed.

Moreover, ongoing measurement and verification of savings are critical for energy performance contracts. Rather than enabling a contractor to measure its performance, government entities should consider requiring the contractor to pay for a third party to escort independent testing of the project advancements to ensure savings are realized.

3. Repel on front-loaded payment schedules

The payment plan for the project is another crucial factor. Contractors will force payments to begin as early as possible, with most of the milestone amounts owing near the front end of the project. This reduces the contractor's financing costs and allows the contractor to switch risk to the government entity before assuring that the project has accomplished the promised savings.

Government bodies should push back on such payment schedules. Most payments should be delayed if feasible until substantial project completion, and initial cost savings from the project improvements are verified.  

4. Scrutinize "guaranteed savings" provisions, which may ensure nothing

Guaranteed savings are the core of an energy performance contract. However, the computation of such savings in the contract is typically complicated by multiple components that obscure the true nature of the guarantee.

As a result, the contract may not truly guarantee the recoupment of specified dollar amounts. For instance, certain savings may be "stipulated" in the contract. If those savings fail to materialize after the project, the government entity bears the burden of the shortfall. Such "stipulated" savings essentially guarantee nothing.

Benchmarks utilized to measure energy savings also may be skewed in favour of the contractor. This may follow in a contractor satisfying the savings benchmark on paper while the government entity has not understood any savings. Though the contractor may report that the savings assurances were satisfied, the government entity could conclude in a poor financial position than before the advancements.

5. Exercise caution as long as water meter system upgrades

Lastly, water meter system updates are particularly problematic. For instance, an energy performance contract may promise "guaranteed savings" through increased revenue generated by a new automated water meter system and avoided costs of operating an old manual system. Nevertheless, these types of projects often fail to guarantee, much less deliver, actual savings or revenue.

For instance, although a contract may ensure that an individual meter accurately measures water intake when tested in a lab, this does not needfully lead to increased revenue. Gathering revenue from water usage needs the transmission of accurate meter readings over the wireless network to the billing system. Without guaranteeing the performance of the water meter system, there is no real guarantee of revenue or "savings" of any kind.

On top of the flimsy assurances of individual meter measurements, the "secured savings" calculation commonly contains "stipulated" savings components that decamp from reality in the field.

The contract assumes that the government entity will realize certain savings from the new water meter system, regardless of whether those savings occur. When the new water meter system becomes more complicated and costly to operate than contemplated by the assumed savings, the government entity is oppressed by those costs into the future. This beats the actual aim of the water meter upgrades.

More in News

Solar energy is gaining momentum, taking a path upward, and it will outshine coal concerning installed capacity- a statement of a great shift toward environmentally friendly energy. This exponential growth of the solar photovoltaic industry indicates that countries, particularly the US and the EU, need to come forward to address the upcoming climate catastrophe. Benefits of Large-Scale Solar Initiatives Utility-scale solar installations have started to shine as models of sustainability and viability. While they are expensive upfront, these large-scale projects’ ongoing operating and maintenance costs are very low. They will start paying for themselves in seven to ten years, where considerable environmental and economic advantages can be derived from them. Solar Power and its Cost-Effectiveness Utility-scale solar installations have minimal operational costs, meaning they will add directly to the affordability of the electrical energy generated by solar. Solar installations enable energy to be provided for less than the cost of production compared with what it would cost if fossil fuels were used. Solar energy becomes economically viable as it depicts a lower LCOE than fossil fuel energy across several regions and time frames. Enabling Self-Sufficiency in Energy Utility-scale solar projects are also fundamental to providing energy for surrounding homes and businesses and jobs to the community. Communities receive better access to electricity if they are not as strongly connected to the grid, and the demand for the larger electrical grid is reduced. They can often be found in remote or rural locations. This empowerment fuels major development in the local economy and its journey to energy independence. Sustainable and Water-Efficient The major environmental benefit that comes with the production of solar energy is that it uses only a tiny volume of water compared to other energy production technologies, which use massive volumes of water basically for cooling. Utilityscale solar projects successfully operate and regulate module temperatures without the use of water through innovative design, hence protecting ecosystems and reducing operating costs. Carbon Emissions Reduction The world must reduce greenhouse gas emissions to transition to renewable energy. Solar energy generates far less CO2 than fossil fuels, making this shift essential for a healthier, greener planet. ...Read more
The energy sector is poised for a transformative year, with several emerging trends poised to redefine how we produce, distribute, and consume energy. These trends, driven by technological advancements, environmental concerns, and shifting consumer preferences, promise to shape the sector's landscape, presenting challenges and opportunities. Renewable energy sources like solar and wind are gaining unprecedented momentum. As technology improves and costs plummet, renewables become more accessible and economically viable, even outpacing traditional fossil fuels in some regions. This shift marks a significant step towards reducing global carbon emissions and diversifying the energy supply, enhancing energy security. Energy storage technology is another area witnessing rapid advancements. Their intermittent nature has always hampered the integration of renewable energy sources into the national grid. However, improvements in battery technology, such as lithium-ion batteries and other innovative storage solutions, are making it possible to store surplus energy generated during peak production times for use during demand spikes. This capability stabilizes the grid and ensures a steady energy supply, regardless of weather conditions. The digitalization of the energy sector is transforming the industry from the inside out. Smart grids, which utilize IoT technology, enable a more efficient and reliable electricity distribution. Smart grids predict and respond to energy demand, reducing waste and saving costs. Additionally, blockchain technology is beginning to play a role in energy trading, allowing for more transparent and efficient transactions. Electrification of transport is another significant trend, with electric vehicles (EVs) becoming increasingly popular. This surge in EV adoption is driven by advancements in battery technology, making EVs more affordable and practical for everyday use. The rise of EVs is expected to lead to a substantial increase in electricity demand, pushing further developments in renewable energy and grid management. The concept of energy efficiency continues to gain traction. Technological advancements and increased awareness are leading households and businesses to invest in energy-efficient appliances, LED lighting, and smart home systems.  ...Read more
The global energy sector is changing. Countries are expanding their renewable energy capacity, upgrading their power infrastructure, diversifying their energy sources and improving energy security. Energy companies are facing a growing range of risks from natural disasters, construction delays, operational disruptions, cyber-attacks, supply chain disruptions, commodity price fluctuation and regulatory requirements changes. The different and interconnected exposures are often not sufficiently covered by existing insurance programs, which lack the necessary flexibility. Alternative risk transfer solutions offer flexible tools to manage high-value or specialized risks faced by organizations, in addition to traditional insurance. Such solutions may include captive insurance arrangements, parametric risk solutions, structured risk financing, multi-year coverage programs, and capital market-based risk transfer models. Across APAC, energy producers, utilities, renewable energy developers, oil and gas companies, transmission operators and infrastructure investors are increasingly looking at these solutions to bolster financial resilience and facilitate long-term investment and business continuity. Emerging Technologies and Growth Drivers Several factors are pushing the energy sector in APAC towards alternative risk transfer solutions. The main growth driver is the rapid development of renewable energy projects in the area, including solar, wind, hydropower, geothermal and energy storage facilities. These projects introduce new operational and financial risks, often necessitating custom risk financing approaches outside traditional insurance products. Natural hazards like typhoons, floods, earthquakes, and wildfires can have a consequential effect on energy infrastructure in many countries in the APAC region. Organizations increasingly are looking for alternative risk transfer structures that offer quicker and more predictable financial recovery from catastrophic events. AI is analyzing operational data, weather patterns, equipment performance and historical loss data to improve risk assessment, which is improving risk modeling and helping to enable more precise pricing of alternative risk solutions. With AI-driven analytics, organizations can gain a better understanding of complex exposure profiles and improve their risk financing strategies. Advanced data analytics and predictive models are enhancing scenario planning to evaluate the impact of operational disruptions, infrastructure failures and market volatility on the bottom line. These insights help organizations build better and more resilient risk-transfer programs. Cloud-based risk management platforms assist in managing insurance programs, captive structures, claims data and operational risks in a centralized manner across geographically sprawled out energy assets. It helps energy companies, insurers, brokers and risk advisors work better together. Industry Trends and Applications Reshaping the APAC Market The solutions offer pre-agreed financial payouts when measurable environmental parameters are triggered, allowing for faster access to capital when qualifying events occur. A further significant trend is the embedding of environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors in risk financing decisions. Energy companies are increasingly combining alternative risk transfer strategies with sustainability goals, climate resilience planning and long-term investment strategies. Cyber risk financing continues to grow as energy infrastructure becomes more digital and connected. Companies are demanding customized risk transfer solutions for operational technology risk, cyber incidents and business interruption related to digital infrastructure. Alternative energy risk transfer solutions are evolving from niche financial instruments to integrated enterprise risk management strategies. A major trend in APAC is the growing use of insurance structures that enable large energy companies to retain selected risks and better manage insurance costs and claims administration over the long term. Parametric risk solutions are gaining momentum, particularly in the renewable energy and infrastructure sectors that are exposed to weather events. Alternative risk transfer solutions provide support for applications spanning renewable energy generation, oil and gas operations, electricity transmission and distribution, liquefied natural gas infrastructure, energy storage facilities, offshore energy projects and industrial energy assets. That flexibility allows organizations to address risks specific to their sector while enabling long-term capital investment and operational resilience. Exploring the Future of Energy Alternative Risk Management Energy alternative risk transfer solutions are strengthening financial resilience by enabling organizations to manage complex and emerging risks more effectively than traditional insurance structures alone. Tailored risk financing better protects capital, improves business continuity planning, and strengthens investment confidence across major energy projects. As APAC continues to grow in renewable energy capacity, grid infrastructure upgrade and investments in energy transition initiatives, demand for alternative risk transfer solutions is expected to grow in the future. AI is likely to take on a bigger role in forecasting risk modeling, portfolio optimization and dynamic underwriting, enabling organizations to create more responsive and data-driven risk financing strategies. As the energy sector in APAC evolves through infrastructure expansion, renewable investment and digital transformation, alternative risk transfer solutions will continue to be vital in supporting resilience, investment stability and sustainable development. Organizations that employ innovative risk financing strategies will be better prepared to deal with uncertainty and drive long-term energy development in the region. Climate analytics and advanced catastrophe modeling are expected to enhance risk assessment by offering a better understanding of environmental exposures and infrastructure vulnerabilities. Enhanced integration of digital risk management platforms, asset monitoring systems and financial analytics will continue to improve enterprise-wide visibility into operational risks and insurance performance.   ...Read more
Commercial and industrial solar panel installations have rapidly gained prominence as an effective means to harness the sun’s abundant energy. Solar power has emerged as a beacon of hope in an era dominated by environmental concerns and the quest for sustainable energy solutions. The burgeoning trend is reshaping the energy landscape, offering many benefits across various sectors. The significant reduction in energy costs is the most compelling reason for businesses to invest in solar panel installations. With solar panels in place, commercial and industrial entities can generate a substantial portion of their electricity needs from the sun. Carbon emissions are significantly reduced when solar panels are installed in commercial and industrial settings. By harnessing clean and renewable solar energy, businesses are taking a decisive step towards a greener future. The transition aligns with corporate social responsibility goals and is a powerful statement of commitment to environmental stewardship. Solar panels provide businesses with a degree of energy independence, reducing their reliance on traditional energy sources and the volatility of energy markets. Solar installations coupled with energy storage systems can ensure a continuous power supply in regions prone to power outages, safeguarding critical operations and minimizing downtime. Governments worldwide recognize solar energy’s pivotal role in combating climate change. They offer a range of incentives and tax benefits to businesses investing in solar installations. The incentives can include tax credits, grants, and rebates, making solar projects more financially appealing and accelerating the return on investment. Commercial and industrial properties with solar panel installations often command higher market values. Studies have shown that solar-powered buildings have a higher resale value and tend to sell faster than their non-solar counterparts. The increase in property value can be a significant long-term benefit for businesses. The solar industry has emerged as a powerful engine for job creation. Local communities benefit from installing, maintaining, and operating solar panels. The growth of the solar sector fosters economic development, attracting investments and stimulating innovation. Commercial and industrial solar installations are highly scalable, accommodating businesses of various sizes and energy needs. Solar solutions can be tailored to meet specific requirements, whether a small enterprise or a large industrial complex. The scalability and flexibility in system design and installation options make solar an adaptable choice for various industries. Embracing solar energy is a powerful statement that resonates with customers, employees, and stakeholders. It aligns the business with the values of a growing, environmentallyconscious consumer base. Adopting commercial and industrial solar panel installations represents a strategic move towards a sustainable and cost-effective energy future. Beyond immediate financial benefits, businesses stand to gain increased environmental credibility, energy independence, and a competitive edge in a rapidly evolving market. ...Read more